Mortgage Experts Blog

< back to blog home

Negative gearing, positive gearing and neutral gearing

Marty McDonald - Tuesday, February 01, 2011

Negative gearing, positive gearing and neutral gearing; you hear these phrases often but I think many people don’t really understand what the terms actually mean. I will outline what excatly what those terms mean as well as briefly explaining why some investors choose to buy negatively geared properties.

Definition of negative, positive and neutral gearing

Put simply negative gearing means an investment asset incurs greater expenses than the income it generates, while positive gearing indicates the investments income is greater than its related expenses. Neutral gearing is off course when expenses and income are equal. If an investment asset is negatively geared an investor can reduce his or her taxable income by the amount of the losses incurred while holding the asset. The types of expenses that can be claimed to reduce income and thus taxable income must be specifically related to the acquisition and maintenance of an income producing asset. For property investors the main deductions are typically loan interest, depreciation, council rates, managing agent fees, maintenance and strata fees if applicable.

Example of negative gearing

The mechanics of negative gearing work like this. Say a property investor earned a salary of $100,000 pa last financial year, received rental income of $20,000 and incurred $30,000 in investment related expenses during the year. The investor’s total income of $120,000 is offset by expenses of $30,000 thus reducing their taxable income to $90,000 which is a gross loss of income of $10,000 when compared to their salary. This reduction in taxable income of $10,000 however means the investor would be liable for income tax and the Medicare levy based on $90,000 not $100,000 which would in turn mean their actual cash flow loss for holding the investment would more like $5500 for the year as they would receive a tax credit of around $4500. This tax credit can be claimed at the end of the year as part of their annual tax return and returned to the investor as a lump sum tax refund or alternatively it is possible to apply for an income tax variation and have their employer take out less tax each pay than would normally be required.

Why do people buy negatively geared property?

Many people ask me why you would buy an investment that has a negative cash flow. Well the answer is threefold.

Firstly the income received from rent is only one portion of the total return the other is off course capital gains. Assuming the investor above purchased the property in question for $500,000 an increase of only 1% or 2% in the property’s value would mean the cash flow loss for that year would be offset by the properties capital gain.
 
Secondly over time it is assumed that rental income will increase to eventually make the property cash flow positive.

Thirdly positive cash flow properties especially those located in major metro areas are hard to find! Off course who knows what will happen in the future rents may stagnate or decrease and property values may also stagnate or decrease, this would make negative gearing a losing strategy all round! However if you forget capital gains for a minute and just consider rental income over time you would expect this to at least rise fairly closely with inflation meaning eventually even if property values decrease any property held long enough should become positively geared.

A rough rule of thumb when considering if a property would be negatively geared, positively geared or neutrally geared:

A really rough guide as to whether a property will be neutrally geared from the outset assuming you borrow 100% of the purchase costs would be the gross yield as compared to prevailing interest rates. Assuming an investor is using the banks money to fund the purchase of a property and with interest rates at about 7% at present a property would need to have around an 8% or 9% yield for it to be neutrally geared. Yield is worked out by dividing annual rental income by the value of a property. For example say a property rents for $300 / week and is purchased for $300,000 the yield would be 5.2% ($300 x 52 / $300,000 % = 5.2%). To get an 8.5% yield a property purchased for $500,000 property would have to rent for $817 / week.

Thanks for taking the time to read my post!

Other pages you may find useful can be found here:

Loan structuring advice for investors

Regards,

Marty McDonald
About the Author: Marty McDonald is principal of mortgage broker “Mortgage Experts”. Marty specialises in assisting active property investors with loan structuring advice and implementation as well as helping credit worthy borrowers with slightly outside the box income and employment situations. Find Marty on and LinkedIn.

What our clients are saying

    "Marty was fantastic! We swore never to use a broker again after bad experiences with other brokers in the past, and our last loan we negotiated ourselves, however this time we needed a mortgage... " – Blake Millgate
    "It is impossible to exaggerate how highly I rate Mortgage Experts and my experience with Marty McDonald... " – Brendan Arlington
    "Mortgage Experts have provided a fantastic experience in an area that can be complicated and emotional. Marty was always clear and precise and always made time to discuss the matters at hand... " – Brett Parker
    "I was really impressed with Marty's services. He was responsive to emails and calls, considered a range of options, and kept me informed at every stage. He was also very patient... " – Elise Darsow
    "Marty was great to deal with. From initial contact to finding a perfect solution and strategy to our situation to then securing the funding in a tight time frame nothing was too much trouble... " – Nick and Blaise Porter
    "Great service! All the advice I've received in the past has been really helpful. Love the newsletters which keep me updated on developments in the market. Highly recommended! " – Nick Jolly
    "I have used Marty's mortgage brokerage service (Mortgage Experts). He has been professional, resourceful, gone beyond the call of duty in servicing my mortgage. He has been able to... " – Prithvi Moses
    "We’re both really happy to have been able to get this sale across the line and are particularly grateful for you finding us a way to make the finance work! Walking into our new home... " – Sarah Macdonald & Stewart Bovell
    "We found Marty McDonald from Mortgage Experts through a Google search because he had a hugely informative page about family trust loans. Choosing Marty as our broker was a huge blessing... " – Tracey Cools

Our Current Lender Panel

Lex Luther Enterprises Pty Ltd (ABN 58114636949) trading as “Mortgage Experts” is an Authorised Credit Representative (444479) of Martin Warren Thomas McDonald, Australian Credit Licence (391230) under s64(1) of the National Consumer Protection Act 2009.